History

When Were Substitutes Introduced in Football? A Sourced History

When were substitutes introduced in football? This sourced history covers the reported 1958 Laws change, early match records and the 1970 World Cup.

Facts last checked

A vintage brown leather football sits beside a pair of old lace-up boots on a dark wooden bench, with a blurred floodlit
A vintage brown leather football sits beside a pair of old lace-up boots on a dark wooden bench, with a blurred floodlit
By Published Updated 7 min read

The question of when substitutes were introduced in football has a commonly cited answer: the International Football Association Board (IFAB), the body that maintains the Laws of the Game, is reported to have added substitution to the Laws in 1958. That date comes from Wikipedia and an undated blog, and it has not yet been checked against IFAB records, so it is treated here as reported rather than confirmed.

Before that, most matches allowed no changes at all, with rare exceptions such as a serious injury or the late arrival of players. Mid-1860s match records mention substitutes, but it is unclear whether they replaced absent or injured players. The first World Cup to allow substitutes is reported to be Mexico 1970, with one substitute per team.

This history sets out each step, and marks which dates are better sourced and which still need verification.

Quick answer: Substitutes were first written into the Laws of the Game by IFAB in 1958, according to Wikipedia and one undated blog, but that date still needs checking against IFAB records before it is stated as fact. The first World Cup to allow substitutes was Mexico 1970, with one substitute per team, according to fanpick.org.

Football before substitutes

For most of football’s early history, a team that lost a player during a match simply carried on with fewer. According to Wikipedia’s entry on substitutes, most matches before substitutes were allowed permitted no changes at all. The rare exceptions it mentions were a serious injury or the late arrival of players. That is a reported summary, not a rule we have checked against a primary document.

For a casual fan, the idea is simple. Imagine your team’s best defender is hurt in the first half. Without substitutes, the coach could not bring anyone on. The team would play on a player short, or the injured player might stay on the pitch in a reduced role. The sources we have do not describe what teams did in individual cases, so we do not go further than that.

Who writes the rules

The rules of football are called the Laws of the Game. They are maintained by the International Football Association Board, known as IFAB, which is the body that decides whether and how the Laws change. Any change to who can be replaced, and when, has to pass through it. The Football Association is among the entities linked to this story, but our sources do not say what role it played in any substitution decision, so we make no claim about that here.

An early hint, with a caution

Substitutes may appear in football’s records earlier than many fans expect. Wikipedia says match records from the mid-1860s mention substitutes. It also says it is unclear whether those players replaced someone who was absent or someone who was injured during play. That difference matters. Filling a gap before kick-off is not the same as swapping a player mid-match, and the record does not settle which was meant. We treat this as an open question.

Sourcing is also thin for this period. The material behind this article rests on Wikipedia and several blogs, and we have not yet checked IFAB or FIFA documents. Dates and numbers are therefore labelled as reported, not confirmed, as the story moves forward.

How the substitution rule grew step by step

The rule did not arrive in one move. On the reported record, it grew in steps, and the dates below are labelled by how well they are sourced. None has yet been checked against IFAB or FIFA documents.

1958: substitution enters the Laws of the Game

According to Wikipedia, the International Football Association Board (IFAB), the body that maintains the Laws of the Game, first added substitution to the Laws in 1958. One undated blog gives the same year. That is thin support for a landmark date. The year has not been verified against IFAB history pages or the Board’s own minutes, so treat it as reported, not confirmed. The sources we hold do not establish how many players a team could replace under that first wording, and we do not state a number.

1970: the World Cup opens the door

A polished silver trophy stands on a white plinth in the foreground, with floodlit and a green pitch with a goal blurred
A polished silver trophy stands on a white plinth in the foreground, with floodlit and a green pitch with a goal blurred

The first World Cup to allow substitutes was the 1970 tournament in Mexico, according to fanpick.org. The same site says each team could use one substitute. For a casual fan, this is the clearest reference point in the story: the sport’s biggest tournament accepted changes during a match for the first time. The claim rests on a single publication, and we have not seen a FIFA source for it. We name no player or match from that tournament, because none is sourced.

Two from five, then three from seven

Fanpick.org also describes later steps. First, two substitutes from a bench of five, with the year given as 1988. Then three substitutes from a bench of seven, dated to 1995.

Both dates need caution. The 1988 date conflicts with other sources, and the research behind this article also found that fanpick.org is not consistent with itself on early dates. The 1995 date is reported by one source only. We therefore cannot say when either change took effect, only that the sequence of numbers is reported as moving from one, to two, to three. Until IFAB records are checked, the years should be read as provisional.

2020: five substitutions, as a temporary measure

In 2020, a temporary allowance of five substitutions was introduced, according to thetitansfa.com, which links it to player welfare. The word “temporary” matters. We have not confirmed with IFAB or FIFA whether the allowance later became permanent, so this article does not describe it as the current rule. Readers who want the present number of substitutes in a particular competition should check the current Laws of the Game and that competition’s own regulations.

What the pattern suggests

A top-down tactical diagram of a green football pitch with four coloured player figures, circular tokens, dashed and solid
A top-down tactical diagram of a green football pitch with four coloured player figures, circular tokens, dashed and solid

Looking across these steps, the numbers rise from none, to one, to several. In our view, that reflects a growing focus on tactics and player welfare, and the thetitansfa.com piece reads the shift in similar terms. This is an interpretation, not a sourced fact. The sources do not record why IFAB acted at each stage, and we do not claim to know.

StepReported changeReported byStatus
1958Substitution first added to the LawsWikipedia; one undated blogNot verified against IFAB
1970World Cup in Mexico allows one substitute per teamfanpick.orgSingle source
1988Two substitutes from a bench of fivefanpick.orgDate conflicts with other sources
1995Three substitutes from a bench of sevenfanpick.orgDate unverified
2020Temporary allowance of five substitutionsthetitansfa.comPermanence unconfirmed

Why the change still matters

Whatever the exact dates turn out to be, the direction of travel is clear: football moved from a game where a side usually played on with whatever players it had left to one where changes are a normal part of the match. In our view, that shift is one of the quieter but more far-reaching rule changes in the sport.

The sources describe the old situation plainly. According to Wikipedia, most matches before substitutes were allowed permitted no changes at all, with rare exceptions such as serious injury or the late arrival of players. A team that lost a player to injury could be left a man short for the rest of the game, and the match could be decided by who was hurt rather than who played better.

What substitutes changed

Substitutes gave managers a way to respond. An injured player could be replaced, a tired one could be swapped for a fresh pair of legs, and a side chasing a game could change its shape. The numbers allowed grew in steps, according to fanpick.org: one substitute at the 1970 World Cup, then two from a bench of five, then three from a bench of seven. The dates it gives for the last two steps are unverified, and the 1988 date conflicts with other sources, so we do not rely on them here.

The shift is widely read as reflecting a growing focus on tactics and player welfare, according to thetitansfa.com. That is an interpretation rather than a recorded fact, and we offer it as the publication’s view too: squads are now built around depth, and the bench is part of the plan rather than an emergency measure.

Check the current Law

Football has not stood still since those steps. thetitansfa.com reports a temporary allowance of five substitutions in 2020, but whether it became permanent has not been confirmed. We have not checked the current number against a primary source, so we do not give one here. For the exact wording of today’s Law, readers should consult the Laws of the Game published by the International Football Association Board (IFAB) on its official website.

Frequently asked questions

Do sources agree on the year substitutes were first added to the Laws of the Game?

Not fully. Wikipedia says the International Football Association Board (IFAB) first added substitution to the Laws of the Game in 1958. The sources reviewed for this article are Wikipedia and an undated blog, and no IFAB or FIFA primary source has been checked. Treat 1958 as reported, not confirmed.

Why do sources disagree on the dates of the early substitution steps?

The sources reviewed are mostly blogs and a reference site, and they do not always agree. One page, fanpick.org, gives 1988 for two substitutes from a bench of five and 1995 for three from seven. That 1988 date conflicts with other sources, and neither date has been checked against IFAB records. We therefore treat both as unverified.

What was the 2020 temporary five-substitution allowance?

According to thetitansfa.com, a temporary allowance of five substitutions was introduced in 2020, reportedly linked to player welfare. Whether it later became permanent has not been confirmed here. Check the current Laws of the Game with IFAB for today’s rule rather than relying on this historic note.

Who sets the Laws of the Game and where can I read the official text?

The International Football Association Board (IFAB) is the body that sets the Laws of the Game. It is the organisation that, according to Wikipedia, first added substitution in 1958. The official, current text is published by IFAB, and that is the place to check how many substitutes are allowed today.

Did early matches ever allow a player to be replaced by someone else?

Sometimes, though not as a regular right. According to Wikipedia, most matches before substitutes were allowed permitted no changes, with rare exceptions such as serious injury or late arrival of players. Mid-1860s match records also mention substitutes, but it is unclear whether they replaced absent or injured players.

Which sources should I trust when checking substitution history?

Trust primary sources first: IFAB’s Laws of the Game and its history pages, and FIFA records for the World Cup. Our research relied on Wikipedia and several blogs, which are useful starting points but are not authoritative. Where they differ, as with the 1988 and 1995 dates, wait for an IFAB or FIFA source before treating a date as settled.

Sources

  1. Five substitutes option temporarily allowed for competition organisers — theifab.com, May 8, 2020 · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  2. The IFAB permanently approves five-substitute option in top-level competitions — inside.fifa.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  3. Importance of Football Substitutes: Key Role in Matches — thetitansfa.com, April 8, 2025 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  4. Substitution Rules: The Evolution Of Substitution Rules In Football — extratimetalk.com, May 22, 2026 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  5. Benefits and Challenges of Being Substituted in Football — thetitansfa.com, April 23, 2024 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  6. The Rise of the Super-Sub: How Substitute Players Changed World Cup History — fanpick.org, July 6, 2026 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  7. Football Substitution Rules in 2025: How Many Subs can be made? — footballpark.com, November 14, 2025 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  8. Substitution Rules in Football: How Many Changes? — allfootball.ke, July 25, 2026 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  9. Substitutions in football: how the five substitute rule and the three windows work — socceraddicted.com, September 22, 2026 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  10. Substitute (association football) — Grokipedia — grokipedia.com, January 15, 2026 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  11. Current Football Substitution Rules: How Many Subs Can Be Made? — sportsboom.com, April 24, 2024 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  12. Soccer Substitution Rules: Everything You Need To Know (+ Rules By League) — jobsinfootball.com, October 19, 2023 · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  13. First substitution at a FIFA World Cup — guinnessworldrecords.com, July 13, 2017 · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  14. How substitution boards have changed over the past 30 years – nss sports — nss-sports.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  15. Mad experiments & ignoring fans: A history of football law-makers – Football Supporters' Association — thefsa.org.uk · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  16. Substitution and beyond — socceramerica.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  17. History of the Laws of the Game — isrscork.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  18. Number of Substitutions in Soccer (And Reason for the Limit) — yoursoccerhome.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  19. (PDF) The effect of an additional substitution in association football: Evidence from the Italian Serie A — researchgate.net · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  20. Football Substitution Rules — kickofflive.online · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  21. Soccer Substitution Rules 101: Everything You Need to Know — soccercoachingpro.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  22. Soccer Substitution Rules: How Many & When — legionreport.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  23. Mexico, 1970: World Cup Football Host — topendsports.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  24. How Many Substitutions Are Allowed in FIFA World Cup 2026 Matches? — beinsports.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  25. Football World Cup 1970 in Mexico — footballhistory.org · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  26. How do substitutions work in soccer? Explaining World Cup substitution rules — fansided.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  27. IFAB: Five substitutions to be allowed on a permanent basis — soccer.nbcsports.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  28. IFAB institutes temporary amendment to allow five substitutes per game — mlssoccer.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  29. Five Substitutions in Soccer Matches to Be Permitted on Permanent Basis — si.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  30. IFAB Approves Five Substitutions, Optional VAR on Temporary Basis as Leagues Resume — si.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  31. www.malaymail.com — malaymail.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  32. Five subs Euro 2020 impact — pressreader.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  33. Temporary change to five substitutions will become a permanent fixture in football, soccer's lawmakers decide — cbssports.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  34. www.malaymail.com — malaymail.com · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  35. Substitute (association football) — en.wikipedia.org · Retrieved October 13, 2026
  36. International Football Association Board — en.wikipedia.org · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  37. World Cup of Masters — en.wikipedia.org · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  38. 1970 FIFA World Cup — en.wikipedia.org · Retrieved October 25, 2026
  39. List of FIFA World Cup red cards — en.wikipedia.org · Retrieved October 25, 2026

One response to “When Were Substitutes Introduced in Football? A Sourced History”

  1. […] years, many fans wanted football to take human error out of goal decisions. According to Al Jazeera, that call for technology had […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest stories