In 1925 the offside law changed from requiring three opponents between an attacker and the goal line to requiring two, and sources describe the shift that followed as the WM formation and its third back. The change is recorded as taking effect in the 1925-26 season, with Arsenal v Tottenham Hotspur on 29 August 1925 reported as the first league match under the new law, and Herbert Chapman’s first game in charge of Arsenal. Fans often merge three separate things: the law change, the weakness it exposed in the old 2-3-5 shape, and the response credited to Chapman’s Arsenal. This article keeps them apart, gives the dates, and flags where sources disagree, including the vote date (8 June or 13 June 1925) and who first had the idea of the third back. All claims here are reported by secondary sources, not confirmed from primary records.
Quick answer: The 1925 law change reduced the number of opponents needed to keep an attacker onside from three to two, which left teams playing with two defenders as the last line and made the old 2-3-5 shape vulnerable. Sources describe Herbert Chapman’s Arsenal responding by pulling a midfielder back into defence, the shift later known as the WM, but who devised the third back is disputed. The vote date is also contested: 8 June 1925 in Football League sources and 13 June 1925 in IFAB sources.
Before 1925: the three-opponent law and the 2-3-5 problem
The offside law in force before 1925 asked a simple thing of an attacker: three opponents had to be between him and the goal line when the ball was played to him. According to voor.sport, that three-opponent requirement first appeared in the FA’s laws in 1863. Wikipedia’s “1925 in sports” entry describes the 1925 amendment as a change from three opponents to two, which implies the three-opponent wording stayed in place until then.
The change did not arrive quickly. According to footbolno.com, the Scottish FA pushed from 1893 to cut the number from three to two. IFAB rejected the proposal in 1894, 1902 and 1913, so the idea had been argued over for roughly three decades before it passed. We have not retrieved IFAB or FA minutes for those votes, so the dates rest on that secondary source.
The 2-3-5 formation grew up under the three-opponent rule. Coaches’ Voice describes it as a pyramid: two full-backs, three half-backs, and five forwards, with three of them playing narrow. The centre-half sat in the middle of the half-back line, with a foot in midfield and a foot in defence.
In our view, and this is analysis rather than something the sources state in these terms, the three-opponent rule shaped how that defence worked. Two full-backs plus a goalkeeper met the requirement on their own. A pair of backs could hold a deep line and push up to catch a forward offside without the same exposure a two-opponent rule would create. The sources we hold do not set out the mechanics of the early offside trap in detail, so we do not describe any specific team’s use of it here.
That is the background to the 1925 change. The next section covers the trial match, the vote dates that sources dispute, and how Arsenal responded.
How the 1925 change unfolded, and where sources disagree
The sequence runs from a February trial to a June vote, then to Arsenal’s first season under a new manager. Every date below is reported by secondary sources. We retrieved no primary minutes from the Football League, the Football Association or IFAB.
The February trial
On 14 February 1925, two Football League games were played under a trial of the new offside law, according to the Woolwich Arsenal blog. One of them was Arsenal against Huddersfield Town. Huddersfield won 5-0, per the same source. The blog describes the heavy defeat as helping to convince Arsenal’s chairman, Sir Henry Norris, to change manager. That is the blog’s interpretation, not a documented board decision.
A vote with two dates
The law was changed from three opponents to two in 1925, as Wikipedia’s 1925 in sports entry records. The exact date of the vote is where sources part ways.
- The Woolwich Arsenal blog says the Football League voted to adopt the change on 8 June 1925.
- Betzoid places an IFAB vote in Paris on 13 June 1925.
The two accounts may describe different bodies meeting on different days, or one may be mistaken. Without the minutes we cannot say which, and we treat the date as disputed. What the sources agree on is the year and the outcome.
Chapman arrives
Herbert Chapman became Arsenal manager on 11 June 1925 after leaving Huddersfield Town, according to the Woolwich Arsenal blog. If the 8 June date is correct, he took the job days after the vote. If 13 June is correct, he was appointed two days before it. Either way, he was in post well before the season began.
The first league match under the new law was Arsenal against Tottenham Hotspur on 29 August 1925, the same blog reports. It was also Chapman’s first game in charge, and Charlie Buchan made his Arsenal debut in it. We have no verified lineup or shape for that match, so we do not say how Arsenal lined up.
Who thought of the third back?

Britannica describes Chapman’s system as a response to the change: the centre-half, previously a midfielder, was withdrawn into defence. That much is the common thread. The origin of the idea is less settled.
Spartacus Educational reports Tom Whittaker as saying that Buchan suggested a defensive centre-half, or a third full-back, to block the middle, with an inside forward dropping back to fill the gap. This is a secondhand account, and we do not present it as Whittaker’s own words. Wikipedia’s treatment of Buchan also credits him with a part in the idea. The Woolwich Arsenal blog, drawing on Buchan’s autobiography, tells the story differently. We have not seen the autobiography, so we cannot adjudicate.
Coaches’ Voice goes further, saying Chapman was not necessarily the inventor of the WM. In our view, the careful reading is that Chapman and Arsenal are credited with developing and popularising the shape, while sole authorship is not established by the sources we hold.
The stopper arrives
Herbie Roberts is the player most tied to the role. According to Wikipedia, he was converted into the stopper centre-half in the WM set-up, replacing Jack Butler in that position. He signed in December 1926 and made his debut in April 1927.
The dates matter for the sequence. Roberts arrived more than a year after the first season under the new law, so he cannot have been part of Arsenal’s first response. The stopper role as Roberts played it came later in the story. We have not verified when Arsenal first used a back three in a league match, and we do not offer a date.
Why the third back still matters in the tactics debate
The third back outlived the law that prompted it. According to Conceptdraw, the WM was widely adopted in English football by the late 1930s, so within roughly a decade of the 1925 change the shape had spread well beyond Arsenal. Wikipedia’s biography of Herbert Chapman records that his Arsenal won five league titles and two FA Cups in the 1930s. Those honours are the main reason the formation is tied so closely to his name.
Credit, and what is still unsettled
That link is also where care is needed. Coaches’ Voice, in a piece we have paraphrased here and not quoted, says Chapman was not necessarily the inventor of the WM. The wording has not been checked against the original, so it is a paraphrase only. Britannica describes his system as withdrawing the midfield centre-half into defence in response to the change. In our view, the safest reading is that Chapman and Arsenal are credited with developing and popularising the shape. Who first devised it remains a matter on which sources differ.
What the goal figures show
The scoring numbers are often quoted as proof that the law worked, but each comes from a different measure and they should not be added together. Footbolno says Football League goals rose from about 4,700 to 6,373 in one season. Separately, Wikipedia’s page on the 1925-26 Football League gives First Division goals rising from 1,192 to 1,703 in 1925-26. Both point the same way, and neither isolates the law change from every other influence on scoring. The numbers suggest a clear rise in goals. They do not, on their own, show how much of it the law caused.
Sportyaura adds that the offside trap did not disappear after 1925, but that the game shifted towards more open play. For tactics readers, that is a useful corrective to the idea of a clean break. Defending with offside remained a tool, and the new law changed the arithmetic around it.
The modern echo
Back-three shapes keep returning in modern football. One fan explainer, from The Titans FA, links the idea to Manchester City under Guardiola. That is an editorial comparison and not established history, and a modern back three does not work like the 1920s WM. What carries over is the question the 1925 change forced: how many defenders a team needs behind the ball, and who covers the middle.
Frequently asked questions
Was the 1925 change the only reason teams began using a third defender?
Sources point to the law change as the trigger, but none retrieved here treats it as the sole cause. The law moved from three opponents to two in 1925, and Britannica describes Chapman’s system as pulling the midfield centre-half back into defence in response. Who devised the idea, and how much came from Arsenal specifically, is disputed.
Who first came up with the idea of a defensive third back?
The sources disagree. Spartacus Educational, citing Tom Whittaker, says Charlie Buchan suggested a defensive centre-half or third full-back with an inside forward dropping back, though that is a secondhand account. Wikipedia and the Woolwich Arsenal blog differ on Buchan’s role. Coaches’ Voice says Herbert Chapman was not necessarily the inventor of the WM.
Did the offside trap vanish once the law changed in 1925?
Not according to Sportyaura, which says the offside trap did not disappear after 1925 but that the game shifted towards more open play. That is one secondary source. Claims linking Bill McCracken to the trap come from aggregator and fan-blog sources and are unverified, so treat them as reported only.
When did the WM become the standard shape in English football?
No source retrieved gives an exact date. Conceptdraw says the WM was widely adopted in English football by the late 1930s, which is the only timing available. The brief has no verified lineup for the first use of the WM and no verified date for Chapman’s first WM match, so neither is stated here.
Which goal figures about the change can I rely on?
All are reported, not confirmed, and they measure different things, so do not combine them. One source says Football League goals rose from about 4,700 to 6,373 in a season. Wikipedia’s 1925-26 season page gives First Division goals rising from 1,192 to 1,703. A goals-per-game estimate, about 2.5 to over 3.5, comes from a secondary source and should be used with caution.
What did Herbie Roberts actually do in the WM set-up?
According to Wikipedia, Herbie Roberts was converted into the stopper centre-half, replacing Jack Butler in that position. He signed for Arsenal in December 1926 and made his debut in April 1927. That makes him the player associated with the third back role, though he did not play in the 1925 matches discussed above.
Sources
- UEFA.com works better on other browsers · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 1925: Arsenal’s pre-season. The arrival of Chapman · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Football Offside Rule Explained: History, Changes & SAOT – StatsUltra · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- What Is IFAB? Who Makes and Changes Football's Laws · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Offside Rule Evolution From 1863 to VAR · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Offside Rule Changes History Explained · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- When Was the Offside Rule Introduced? The Full Timeline · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- The 1925 Offside Rule: How One Change Transformed Football Forever · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- How the Offside Law Evolved from Early Football to the VAR Era · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 14 February 1925: the first trial of the new offside rule · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Offside in Football · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- How the Offside Rule Has Evolved in Football History · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Association football (soccer) formation 3-2-5 (WM) · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- The W-M formation: football tactics explained – Coaches' Voice · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Herbie Roberts · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Mastering the WM Formation: Complete Guide · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Who was Herbert Chapman? – Arsenal Supporters Club · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- The History of Offside by Julian Carosi www.corshamref.org.uk 1 · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- The history of soccer’s offside rule and where it’s heading • Top World Football · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- History of the Laws of the Game · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Offside Rules, History And Development · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- The offside law, Bill McCracken and, a century on, the decision that changed football forever · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Arsenal anniversaries 14 Feb. The league game with experimental offside rules · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Experimenting with the offside law as Arsenal lose 6 in a row, scoring just 2. · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Arsenal vs. Huddersfield Town – 14 February 1925 – Soccerway · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Arsenal in the 1930s. The cup winners who dropped out and the players who came in · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- TheCentreBack – scotsfootballworldwide.scot · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Herbie Roberts: how can Arsenal forget this wonderful player? · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Roberts Herbert Image 4 Arsenal 1935 – Vintage Footballers · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Herbie Roberts · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Arsenal’s Greatest Defenders · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Herbie Roberts facts for kids · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Formation (association football) · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Offside (field hockey) · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Offside (American football) · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 192526 Football League · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 1925 in sports · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Herbie Roberts · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Charlie Buchan · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Herbert Chapman · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- WM formation · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- International Football Association Board · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 192425 Arsenal F.C. season · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 193536 Arsenal F.C. season · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 192324 Arsenal F.C. season · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- 192425 Huddersfield Town A.F.C. season · Retrieved October 12, 2026
- Jack Butler (footballer, born 1894) · Retrieved October 12, 2026







Leave a Reply